Any tool can be broken under the wrong circumstances.
...
It has 4.6 stars…. Wich is pretty good.
While it's true that you can break any tool if used incorrectly, I like to read more into the reviews than that. If you look at the reviews for the OEMTools (green) puller, there are multiple people who say it just broke.
In comparison, the
$300 Tiger Tool puller, which is the gold standard, has over 2x the reviews, and a similar 4.7/5 rating, but READ them. There are none that say it broke. Instead, most of the less-than-5/5 ratings are for it not fitting the user's application.
- 2/5: "Great tool, if it fits your application"
- 4/5: "Works, but be careful" (u-joint cap was stuck, and he bent the yoke instead!)
- 2/5: "May want to double check" (didn't fit his)
- 4/5: "Thought this tool be a perfect fit. WRONG" (didn't fit his)
- 1/5: "Bent Casting Tool" (manufacturing quality error, not from use)
- 4/5: "" (didn't fit his)
Overall, that's a VERY different story. And if idiots were just breaking the green ones by using them wrong, you'd think the same idiots would show up on the Tiger Tool's reviews, but not one to be found.
Everyone will have to decide for themselves, but
I'm too poor to buy cheap tools. Yes, this is a single purpose tool, and pulling the joint is possible to do without it (e.g. if the cheap one were to break in the field), but I like knowing that I have a good one I can depend on.