I read of a lot of ppl here saying they have had Hagerty (or American Classics) for years and NEVER had a problem. What they forget to mention is that they NEVER HAD A CLAIM, you pay + they cash = NO PROBLEM of course.
I read horror stories about Hagerty requesting your cellular bill for the month of the date of the accident and other absurd things never heard of before and taking your car to someone else's garage for the sake of a nice picture will come back and bite ya in the ass when it's time to claim. Remember insurance companies need to try to disburse as little as possible and they will come up with anything they can to try to deny the claim. This is less pronounced with majors like GEICO, PROGRESSIVE, SF and ALLSTATE. You have to be very very careful when you have those conversations over a recorded line, if you "Stretch the Truth" you may be getting into a big problem that will only be discovered when it's too late.
Example, some people have insured their 2006 Humvee as a 2006 Hummer H1 just because the AM General option was not available and after all is the same car... right....? Sometimes we go round and round just to have an agent tell us what we want to hear, but that agent won't be there when the claim is rejected.
My advice....? Record your telephone conversations (which is allowed since they are doing it too) and try to specify the details that are going to CYA later, the agent wants to sell and yo want to buy and that is the phase of the negotiation where things get accepted a little more leniently, make a journal with notes with the name of the Agent and date/time of the convo, believe it or not that carries weight in front of a judge.
If you obtain insurance via stretching the truth, you just put a bandaid on skin cancer.
10 years in a law firm taught me a thing or two about insurance claims.
ohhh... did I mention that your agent will put some discounts like Anti-Lock brakes on your Humvee (what a joke!) just to make the premium a little more inviting and one day you will run over someone that crossed a dark road and killed them. Now the insurance is looking at millions of liability dollars and they will go and examine the swerving of your skid marks and determine that if you indeed had anti-lock brakes that person may still be alive, so you say
"But I never said I had A/L !"
and the DA:
"But when the Agent, as we hear in the recorded conversation, said that you were receiving an A/L discount , you DID NOT correct the record and accepted the discount...didn't you..."
I am telling you guys....