The free one was worth what you paid for it, hope you don't take a bath on the other.I have learned my lesson to keep up with them. another thing though its a 3 year warranty free replacement not prorated like some batteries. I got one for free and the other for 100 bucks so I couldent go wrong. I dont think I would buy another one though.
You have room for full size batteries in that rig, I am not sure why you want to restrict your battery bank to a couple of optima car batteries. You are giving up much of your reserve capacity with that choice.