So, as it turns out, my handles were not worn out, the rod from the lock lever to the door handle was disconnected. My handles were pretty fugly so I would have changed them out ultimately anyway. On the bright side, I now know what the clanky noise is that I hear in both doors when I go around corners. Passenger door done, will have to wait until the weather coming is gone through since I can't finish a door the same day I start it due to painting the spacer and having to let the paint dry overnight.
Some things I learned that I'll share to save the next guy some headache. Keep in mind, this an A1R with the gen 2 trimark handles.
1) the latches from MWME are not identical to the what was used at the factory. There is one unused plastic rod clip you need to remove and the lever that the round lock knob goes into has two holes in it rather than one. You need to install the little rod that goes through the door panel in the top hole. The hole is also larger than the original so the rod will be swimming in the hole and you just have to hold it in place to tighten it down in the center.
2) MWME sells the latches, but they don't sell the gaskets or spacers. The link I posted above is for the correct gaskets and you need two per handle as GD said. The lamination is door handle/gasket/spacer/gasket. The part number for the passenger side spacer is 19207-12423653 MFG # 0FW39. I know from talking to Joe at MWME that the TM's show a left and right gasket, so they probably show a left and right spacer. The gaskets are the same, one size fits all, and the only difference I can see in the spacer would be that the spacer has a slight curve to match the door, so in a pinch the same part would work for both sides. When I do the drivers side, I’ll get the spacer part number and post it here.